The BMW was left in the driveway of a High Ridge Road homeowner, who reported the driver getting into the Range Rover with three other occupants that sped off around 6 a.m., Lt. Christopher Hawken said.
A wallet was taken from another vehicle on High Ridge that was burglarized, he said.
As officers responded, a call came in to police headquarters from a Surrey Lane resident that the stolen Range Rover was hers.
The 2011 BMW, with a Pennsylvania license plate and body damage, turned out to be stolen out of Newark on Monday, responders said.
Click here to follow Daily Voice Garfield-Lodi and receive free news updates.